How Do I Know If the Farrier Is Good?
What horse owners should really look for when choosing (and keeping) a farrier.
If you’ve ever found yourself watching your farrier work and wondering, “Is this person doing a good job?” you’re not alone. Choosing the right farrier can feel a bit overwhelming, especially when you're not exactly sure what “good” shoeing or trimming looks like. But a great farrier is absolutely essential to your horse’s health and performance and finding one shouldn’t feel like solving a mystery.
So let’s break it down. Here are some signs you’ve got a good farrier on your team or a few red flags to keep an eye out for.
Signs of a Good Farrier
Your Horse Stays Sound
If your horse is regularly sore after trims or shows signs of lameness, something might be off. While not every issue is hoof-related, a good farrier will help your horse stay sound or alert you quickly if something needs veterinary attention.
They Take Their Time and Pay Attention
Good farriers don’t rush through the job like they’re late for lunch. They watch how your horse stands and moves, check balance, look for hoof issues, and make adjustments as needed. It’s not just about slapping on a shoe.
They Communicate With You (and Your Vet, If Needed)
If your farrier notices an issue with thrush, cracks, uneven wear they should talk to you about it. Even better? When farriers are willing to team up with your vet for issues like hoof balance concerns, laminitis, navicular, corrective shoeing or long-term rehab plans.
Your Horse Stands Quietly for Them
Horses aren’t shy about telling us how they feel. If your horse normally behaves but gets anxious or fidgety around a certain farrier, it might be worth paying attention. A calm, confident farrier with good handling skills can make all the difference. Patience is very important, especially when working with young or green horses, or senior horses who may have a harder time standing on 3 legs.
The Feet Look Balanced and Healthy
Even if you’re not a hoof expert, you can look for symmetry, even wear, and a natural-looking trim or shoeing job. Hooves shouldn’t look choppy, cracked, or uneven. And long toes, underrun heels, or flares are usually a sign it’s time to ask some questions.
They Show Up on Time and Keep a Schedule
Reliability matters. A good farrier sticks to a consistent trim/shoeing schedule and doesn’t ghost you last-minute (unless it’s a true emergency). Huge bonus points if they send reminders or are easy to communicate with.
Red Flags to Watch For
- They ignore or dismiss your concerns.
- Hoof shape changes dramatically from trim to trim.
- Your horse is consistently sore or tender afterward.
- They never explain what they’re doing — or act annoyed when you ask.
- They are reluctant to work with your vet if needed.
- Their work is quick but sloppy, or it always looks rushed.
- They are quick to lose their temper.
A Few Questions You Can Ask
Not sure what to say? Try these:
“Do you see anything with my horse’s feet we should keep an eye on?”
“How often should we trim/shoe based on how my horse grows?”
“Have you worked with horses that do [discipline] before?”
“Is there anything you'd recommend to improve their hoof health?”
A good farrier will never make you feel dumb for asking. In fact, they want educated owners. It makes their job easier and your horse’s life better.
Final Thoughts
Your farrier doesn’t need to be a magician, but they should absolutely be a skilled, thoughtful professional who cares about your horse’s well-being. Trust your instincts. If something feels “off,” it’s okay to get a second opinion.
Remember: your farrier is part of your horse’s care team just like your vet, trainer, or chiropractor. When you find a good one, hold on tight. They're worth their weight in gold (and shoes).
Want to swap farrier tips or hear about others’ experiences? Join the conversation in the TurnoutHQ community your hooves will thank you.
Sources:
American Farrier’s Association (AFA) – americanfarriers.org General standards for professional farriers, signs of quality hoof care, and ethical guidelines.
Dr. Deb Bennett, PhD (Equine Studies Institute) Expert writing on hoof balance, anatomy, and farrier evaluation.
The Horse Magazine – Articles on choosing and evaluating farriers, including:
- “How to Find a Good Farrier” (thehorse.com)
- “Working With Your Farrier: What You Should Expect”
Equus Magazine – “10 Signs of a Good Farrier”